Fans of Jolina Magdangal, the beloved host of ‘Magandang Buhay,’ and Julie Anne San Jose, the acclaimed ‘Asia’s Limitless Star,’ found themselves embroiled in a spirited Twitter debate regarding the coveted title of ‘Pop Icon.’
The tension arose on June 9 when GMA Network unveiled their latest singing competition, ‘The Voice Generations,’ and introduced San Jose as one of the esteemed coaches, holding the prestigious designation of ‘The Pop Icon Coach.’
Following the announcement, Magdangal’s loyal supporters expressed their reservations about San Jose being labeled a pop icon, arguing that she lacks a definitive breakthrough hit in the music industry.
In contrast, fans of Magdangal passionately highlighted her extensive achievements not only in the realm of music but also her influential words, fashion choices, and captivating performances that have left an indelible mark.
“Dear GMA, Pls make it clear, if you may, that Julie Ann is a Music Pop Icon because honestly, for Pop Culture—talking about THE POP ICON it is THE ONLY JOLINA MAGDANGAL.“
Dear GMA,
Pls make it clear, if you may, that Julie Ann is a Music Pop Icon because honestly, for Pop Culture—talking about THE POP ICON it is THE ONLY JOLINA MAGDANGAL. No hate. Just love.
— OzC (@ikeralot__) June 11, 2023
“Jolina Magdangal is one of the best-selling artists, most successful multimedia artists & influential figure in pop culture.”
“May version na ba si Julia Ann ng Doll? Aside sa singing, Jolina is a fashion icon too during 90’s. Loveteam na hindi gross panoorin at talagang kinakikiligan. Top grossing films and jam-packed concert to Araneta without social media (90’s era) do your research.”
San Jose’s dedicated fan base promptly rallied to her defense, asserting that the ‘Pop Icon’ title is more fitting for artists who gained prominence in the ’90s. They argued that Magdangal’s music might not resonate as much with millennials and Gen Z, making her songs unfamiliar to the younger generations.
“90s era pa to beh. Hindi siya kilala ng Gen Zs at younger millennials. Wala akong alam sa mga kanta niya kasi maybe hindi ko naabutan. She’s a POP Icon but not to my generation. Wag kayo mag-invalidate ng success ng mga new pop singers. Sila ang may relevance sa new gen now.”
“Deserve ni Julie Anne San Jose. Bakit? Singer na, dancer pa, actress pa, multi-instrumentalist, singing multilingual songs at song writer pa.Masyado niyo atang minamaliit ang kakayahan ng babaeng ‘to,”
In response to the Twitter uproar ignited by Magdangal’s fans, GMA Network swiftly addressed the controversy by modifying San Jose’s character introduction from ‘The Pop Icon Coach’ to ‘The Limitless Star Coach,’ effectively quelling the dispute.
Jolina – 1
Julie Anne – 0Hahahaha. https://t.co/PsG37U1ABU
— JC Sarmiento (@jcsxict) June 13, 2023
Magdangal, renowned for her illustrious career in the Philippine entertainment industry, encompassing iconic music and generation-defining films, has rightfully earned the esteemed title of ‘Queen of Pinoy Popular Culture.’
On the other hand, San Jose, an accomplished singer, songwriter, actress, host, and television personality, is hailed as “Asia’s Limitless Star” due to her exceptional vocal talent and notable achievements.
While the Twitter battle continues unabated, neither Magdangal nor San Jose has made official statements regarding the matter. Nevertheless, both artists have left an indelible mark on the music industry, boasting remarkable careers and substantial contributions.
Auditions for ‘The Voice Generations’ are presently underway at the GMA Network studios and are scheduled to conclude on June 15. This unique singing competition places a singular focus on vocal ability as contestants vie for an opportunity to showcase their talent on a grand scale.
